When most people think about investing, they picture the same short menu: stocks, bonds, maybe an annuity from an insurance salesman. Mortgage notes almost never make the list — not because they perform poorly, but because nobody ever shows them to you. Banks keep this asset class for themselves. Here is how notes actually stack up against the big three.
First, what is a mortgage note?
A mortgage note is simply a loan secured by real estate. When you own the note, you are the bank. The borrower makes monthly payments of principal and interest to you, and if they stop paying, you have a lien on real property backing you up. You are not buying the property. You are buying the payment stream — and the collateral behind it.
Notes vs. stocks
Stocks offer the highest long-term average returns of the group, and over 30 or 40 years an index fund is hard to beat. The problem is the path you take to get there. The stock market routinely drops 20, 30, even 50 percent, and it does not care whether you were planning to retire that year. Your return depends heavily on when you need the money.
A performing note pays the same amount every month whether the market is up or down. The borrower's obligation does not shrink because the S&P had a bad quarter. Notes also have a feature stocks never will: collateral. If a company goes bankrupt, shareholders are last in line and usually get nothing. If a note borrower defaults, the note holder has a legal claim on the real estate securing the debt.
The trade-off is honest and worth stating plainly: notes will not triple in value. A note's upside is capped at its yield. You are trading the lottery ticket for a paycheck.
Notes vs. bonds
Bonds are the closest cousin to notes — both are debt instruments that pay fixed income. The differences are yield and security.
Investment-grade corporate and government bonds have spent most of the last two decades paying low single digits. Notes purchased at a sensible discount routinely yield 8 to 12 percent. Why the gap? Bonds trade in a massive, liquid, hyper-efficient market where every basis point is competed away. Notes trade in a small, inefficient market with few buyers — and inefficiency is where individual investors get paid.
On security, a bond is backed by the issuer's promise and general creditworthiness. A first-lien mortgage note is backed by a specific, identifiable piece of real estate you evaluated before you bought it. If things go wrong with a bond, you hold paper. If things go wrong with a note, you hold a lien.
The real advantage bonds have is liquidity. You can sell a Treasury in seconds. Selling a note takes weeks. If you may need your principal back on short notice, that matters — and it is why notes belong in the long-term, income-producing part of a portfolio.
Notes vs. annuities
Annuities are sold on exactly the promise notes deliver: predictable monthly income. The difference is what you give up to get it.
With an annuity, you hand an insurance company a lump sum, and they hand you back your own money slowly, keeping the spread and charging fees for the privilege — surrender charges, mortality and expense fees, rider fees. Payout rates are priced so the insurer wins. And with many annuities, when you die, the remaining value dies with you.
A note portfolio does the same job — converting a lump sum into monthly income — except you keep the spread, you control the assets, and when you die the notes pass to your heirs like any other property. The trade-off is that you are doing the work an insurance company would do: selecting the assets and managing them. That work is real, but it is learnable, and it is exactly what the yield premium pays you for.
The side-by-side
| Stocks | Bonds | Annuities | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical return | 7–10% long-term avg | 2–5% | 3–6% payout | 8–12% yield |
| Volatility | High | Low–moderate | None visible | None on performing notes |
| Collateral | None | Issuer's promise | Insurer's promise | Real estate lien |
| Monthly income | Dividends vary | Coupons | Yes, fee-reduced | Yes |
| Liquidity | Instant | Instant | Poor (surrender fees) | Weeks to sell |
| Passes to heirs | Yes | Yes | Often no | Yes |
Where notes fit
Notes are not a replacement for everything else — I say this as someone who owns them full time. They are a complement. Stocks give you growth. Notes give you income you can actually count on, secured by real assets, at yields the bond market stopped offering decades ago. For investors who are tired of watching a decade of gains vanish in a bad quarter, that combination is worth understanding.
Want the full playbook?
My book Lienlord covers how notes work, how to evaluate and price them, and how to build a portfolio that pays you every month. Or grab the first chapter free — no email required.
Get the Book Free Chapter